Historical Data Missing From Charts

[Instamess]

Thanks, but you didn't address my concern about the "design" that dumps good data to replace it with bad data and isn't smart enough to even tell when big chunks of data are missing on your server!

So problem fixed. For today. If it happens again tomorrow we lose more money without knowing that NT is messing us around yet again.

[NinjaTrader_Brandon]

Hello Instamess,

Thanks for your reply.

The missing data has been resolved by switching to the backup server. Restart NinjaTrader and reconnect to connect to the backup server and resolve.

[Instamess]

By design NinjaTrader will reload historical data when connecting to verify your data is accurate as this data typically should be good.

Then by design NT should be smart enough to know when there's data missing on your server and to warn me or give me the option of using the good data I already have!

As it stands now, you erase all my good data, dump a whole load of rubbish data on me (with missing bits) and don't even warn me that you've screwed up my history!

[NinjaTrader_Brandon]

Hello,

Thanks for your replies.

When historical data is found to be missing all that can be done is collecting data of the missing data and report the findings to any relating parties. We work closely with any relating parties to provide any information needed to look into the missing data and help prevent in the future.
By design NinjaTrader will reload historical data when connecting to verify your data is accurate as this data typically should be good.
tradesnoop, at this time the backup server has been verified to be properly functioning. If after restarting NinjaTrader and reloading historical data you charts still do not properly display please report what data is missing.
What instrument?
What chart type is selected? (tick, min, day)
What from and to time is missing?

[tradesnoop]

Thanks

My Thanks to the Support Team and the Technical team that is working on the problem. I know that very little in this world operates 100% flawlessly. NT is a great platform there isn't another platform out there that doesn't experience occasional problems. My feed is acting up like all the others this morning and reloading NT doesn't help. I will work around this until it's fixed. If possible maybe you could keep us informed if you find the issue come up with a timeline for getting things working again. Thanks.

[lawdam]

What I don't understand is when I close NT all my data should be saved to my PC
Once I open NT all the data is still there until I connect to server. WHY?
It makes more sense to just keep on adding to the stored data I already have.
Other wise I have to go back and check that once I connect, it did not wipe out data from my charts, waste of time. I hope NT8 has a fix for this too. I should have the option to restore my data from my saved data on my PC or from your servers by date and time.
Because of this I missed a 12 handle move in ES and a 124 point move in YM.

[Instamess]

first the issue with Zen Fire and now this..

I too was affected by the Zen Fire affair so I know where you're coming from.

Brandon, thanks for the update. But, what's the longer term solution? What assurances can NT give us that the problem has been fixed? Permanently?

When I'm on the live charts and the price isn't moving, it should be because the price isn't moving. I shouldn't be in a perpetual state of wondering whether it's a case of the price not moving or the charts simply not updating.

When I open my charts in the morning I want to trade based on what my indicators are telling me. It should not be the case that I always have to check through past data to see if there's anything missing (and it's not always easy to tell that either!).

Thanks for all your efforts, but given the continued problems, I have this to say to NT:

It's. Not. Good. Enough.

[NinjaTrader_Brandon]

Hello,

Thanks for your posts.

A backup historical data server has been switched to. Please restart NinjaTrader to switch to the backup server. You may need to right click on your chart and select Reload All Historical Data.

[laocoon]

That's ridiculous! You're suggesting we pay for two separate data feeds because NT keeps having this historical data problem and can't fix it?

Again today my charts are all screwed up because of NinjaTrader and missing data. I ain't happy!

I second that. I've been using Ninja for over 10 years and this kind of problem happened only rarely in the past. Unfortunately 2014 has been a nightmare so far: first the issue with Zen Fire and now this. I really have developed a lot of respect and affection for Ninja over the years, but suggesting that we should now use a second data provider for historical data isn't worthy of such a (still) great platform.

[Instamess]

For users that rely on their historical data for analysis it is recommended to have a backup datafeed regardless of what provider you use.

That's ridiculous! You're suggesting we pay for two separate data feeds because NT keeps having this historical data problem and can't fix it?

Again today my charts are all screwed up because of NinjaTrader and missing data. I ain't happy!

[Scott_Mariani]

Thank you...

Brandon,
Thank you for the detailed reply.
Does that mean I need another solution other than Ninja trader or another data feed into Ninjatrader?
Scott

[NinjaTrader_Brandon]

Hello Scott,

Thanks for your post.

In other posts by our CEO Ray, has has informed users "We are currently experiencing a partial outage where our historical data servers are not receiving “last trade” data from the underlying market data source provider."
Our servers team works with the provider and reports our findings to resolve these items and prevent in the future.
This historical data from CQG/Continuum is provided for free to all CQG/Continuum users with NinjaTrader.
For users that rely on their historical data for analysis it is recommended to have a backup datafeed regardless of what provider you use.

You can see the following forum post where Ray had went over what is happening.

http://www.ninjatrader.com/support/forum/showthread.php?t=64531

[Scott_Mariani]

Any explanation as to what is going?

Vince,
Thanks for the response. It is one thing to not have market replay data that is not promised and only used after the fact. As I am sure you are aware, the realtime historical data is required for our indicators and signals to work properly. As a paying customer I would like to understand what happened and what NT is doing to insure it does not happen again?
Thanks,
Scott

[NinjaTrader_VinceB]

Hello,

Just received an update that the missing data for the 6E will be restored this coming weekend.

The data will then be available again on Monday.

[Scott_Mariani]

Historical Data issue with 6E 06-14

Same problem here. Got up at 3am GMT-4 and had no historical data back to 12.00am. When I hit refresh historical data it clears live data and resets back to 12.00 am. 6J is fine. Using CQG with Amp. Called AMP, called CQG, got the famous not me response. Didn't think it was Ninja until I saw this post. What is up? I am really disappointed I missed my trade window this morning.
Scott