Strategy Analyzer Inconsistency

[samish18]

I just checked the trades taken live vs backtesting over the same period and there is a huge discrepancy (I am still waiting on a real answer and some accountability for the erroneous backtests). The trades taken live vs backtest occur at different times. I then reran the strategy analyzer (with all the same settings) and all the trades from the current day were missing. What the hell is going on?

[NinjaTrader_Jesse]

Hello samish18,

I see that you have posted a similar question a few times now, the reason that you are getting the same answer in each post is because debugging the strategy will be necessary to find out what difference happened between those two tests.

It is completely normal for a backtest to not match a realtime run of a strategy for many reasons, I have previously linked a guide that goes over that in the past 2 forum threads that you have started for this topic. At this point you would have to add debugging to the strategy in order to explore what difference is happening. This would not be something our support can answer without specific details which can only be obtained by debugging the strategy.

The guide below is specifically made to go over the topic of comparing results between tests. That is a process the developer of the strategy would have to do themselves during the strategy testing phase or even when running in production if some discrepancy is found between tests.

https://support.ninjatrader.com/s/article/Developer-Guide-Comparing-Strategy-Results?language=en_US