Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Partner 728x90

Collapse

multi time frame strategy tick discrepency

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    multi time frame strategy tick discrepency

    I have a strategy that runs on CL 6 tick Range bar.

    I have also added Tick as a period to process intrabar historicals.

    For most cases all works fine, except on some bars the Ticks and Range bars do not correlate.

    On some bars, the first tick and other ticks are out of the range of the high and low of the bar. On some bars there are only 2 ticks for a 6 tick bars which are out of range also.


    I can demonstrate this issue with the following strategy code :
    Run this on a 5 day 6 Range chart for CL 02-13 contract.

    On the output window, look at bars 146 and 147.

    How can Range bars be correct but ticks be wrong? How can I fix this issues?


    protected override void Initialize()
    {
    Add(PeriodType.Tick,1);
    CalculateOnBarClose = false;
    }

    protected override void OnBarUpdate()
    {
    if ( CurrentBars[0]>150)return;

    // display bar numbers on the chart if(BarsInProgress==0)DrawText("i"+CurrentBar,"_"+C urrentBar,0,High[0]+TickSize,Color.Black);

    Print(CurrentBars[1]+"-Opens[0][0]="+Opens[0][0]+"-Opens[1][0]="+Opens[1][0]+"-Closes[1][0]="+Closes[1][0]+"-"+CurrentBars[0]);

    }

    #2
    Hello afshinmoshrefi,
    Unfortunately I cannot replicate the scenario.

    The first print I am getting is:
    1889-Opens[0][0]=92.13-Opens[1][0]=92.07-Closes[1][0]=92.07-20
    What is the Min- bars required to initialize the strategy. Can you please let me know the exact settings to test it.
    JoydeepNinjaTrader Customer Service

    Comment


      #3
      I create a CL 2-13 contract 6 Range Chart with Days to load = 5
      open output window and then enable the strategy. The issue is around the bars 145,146,147 -

      you should see the out put as follows:

      24337-Opens[0][0]=92.15-Opens[1][0]=92.08-Closes[1][0]=92.08-144
      24337-Opens[0][0]=92.15-Opens[1][0]=92.08-Closes[1][0]=92.08-144
      24338-Opens[0][0]=92.15-Opens[1][0]=92.08-Closes[1][0]=92.08-144
      24339-Opens[0][0]=92.15-Opens[1][0]=92.08-Closes[1][0]=92.08-144
      24340-Opens[0][0]=92.15-Opens[1][0]=92.09-Closes[1][0]=92.09-144
      24341-Opens[0][0]=92.15-Opens[1][0]=92.08-Closes[1][0]=92.08-144
      24342-Opens[0][0]=92.15-Opens[1][0]=92.08-Closes[1][0]=92.08-144
      24343-Opens[0][0]=92.15-Opens[1][0]=92.08-Closes[1][0]=92.08-144
      24344-Opens[0][0]=92.08-Opens[1][0]=92.08-Closes[1][0]=92.08-145
      24344-Opens[0][0]=92.08-Opens[1][0]=92.08-Closes[1][0]=92.08-145
      24345-Opens[0][0]=92.02-Opens[1][0]=92.08-Closes[1][0]=92.08-146
      24345-Opens[0][0]=92.02-Opens[1][0]=92.08-Closes[1][0]=92.08-146
      24346-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.09-Closes[1][0]=92.09-147
      24346-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.09-Closes[1][0]=92.09-147
      24347-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.08-Closes[1][0]=92.08-147
      24348-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.08-Closes[1][0]=92.08-147
      24349-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.07-Closes[1][0]=92.07-147
      24350-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.07-Closes[1][0]=92.07-147
      24351-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.07-Closes[1][0]=92.07-147
      24352-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.07-Closes[1][0]=92.07-147
      24353-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.06-Closes[1][0]=92.06-147
      24354-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.06-Closes[1][0]=92.06-147
      24355-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.06-Closes[1][0]=92.06-147
      24356-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.04-Closes[1][0]=92.04-147
      24357-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.04-Closes[1][0]=92.04-147
      24358-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.03-Closes[1][0]=92.03-147
      24359-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.03-Closes[1][0]=92.03-147
      24360-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.03-Closes[1][0]=92.03-147
      24361-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.03-Closes[1][0]=92.03-147
      24362-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.03-Closes[1][0]=92.03-147
      24363-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.02-Closes[1][0]=92.02-147
      24364-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.02-Closes[1][0]=92.02-147
      24365-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.02-Closes[1][0]=92.02-147
      24366-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.02-Closes[1][0]=92.02-147
      24367-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.02-Closes[1][0]=92.02-147
      24368-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.02-Closes[1][0]=92.02-147
      24369-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.02-Closes[1][0]=92.02-147
      24370-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.02-Closes[1][0]=92.02-147
      24371-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.02-Closes[1][0]=92.02-147
      24372-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24373-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24374-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24375-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24376-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24377-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24378-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24379-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24380-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24381-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24382-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24383-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24384-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24385-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24386-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24387-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.99-Closes[1][0]=91.99-147
      24388-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.99-Closes[1][0]=91.99-147
      24389-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.99-Closes[1][0]=91.99-147
      24390-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.99-Closes[1][0]=91.99-147
      24391-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.98-Closes[1][0]=91.98-147
      24392-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.98-Closes[1][0]=91.98-147
      24393-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.98-Closes[1][0]=91.98-147
      24394-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.98-Closes[1][0]=91.98-147
      24395-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.97-Closes[1][0]=91.97-147
      24396-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.97-Closes[1][0]=91.97-147
      24397-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.97-Closes[1][0]=91.97-147
      24398-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.97-Closes[1][0]=91.97-147
      24399-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.97-Closes[1][0]=91.97-147
      24400-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.96-Closes[1][0]=91.96-147
      24401-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.96-Closes[1][0]=91.96-147
      24402-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.96-Closes[1][0]=91.96-147
      24403-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.96-Closes[1][0]=91.96-147
      24404-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.96-Closes[1][0]=91.96-147
      24405-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.96-Closes[1][0]=91.96-147
      24406-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.96-Closes[1][0]=91.96-147
      24407-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.95-Closes[1][0]=91.95-147
      24408-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.95-Closes[1][0]=91.95-147
      24409-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.95-Closes[1][0]=91.95-147
      24410-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.95-Closes[1][0]=91.95-147
      24411-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.95-Closes[1][0]=91.95-147
      24412-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.95-Closes[1][0]=91.95-147
      24413-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.95-Closes[1][0]=91.95-147
      24414-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.95-Closes[1][0]=91.95-147
      24415-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.95-Closes[1][0]=91.95-147
      24416-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.94-Closes[1][0]=91.94-147
      24417-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.93-Closes[1][0]=91.93-147
      24418-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.93-Closes[1][0]=91.93-147
      24419-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.93-Closes[1][0]=91.93-147
      24420-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.93-Closes[1][0]=91.93-147
      24421-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.93-Closes[1][0]=91.93-147
      24422-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.93-Closes[1][0]=91.93-147
      24423-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.93-Closes[1][0]=91.93-147
      24424-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.92-Closes[1][0]=91.92-147
      24425-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.92-Closes[1][0]=91.92-147
      24426-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.92-Closes[1][0]=91.92-147
      24427-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.92-Closes[1][0]=91.92-147
      24428-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24429-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.02-Closes[1][0]=92.02-147
      24430-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.02-Closes[1][0]=92.02-147
      24431-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24432-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24433-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92-Closes[1][0]=92-147
      24434-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92-Closes[1][0]=92-147
      24435-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24436-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.02-Closes[1][0]=92.02-147
      24437-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.02-Closes[1][0]=92.02-147
      24438-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24439-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24440-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92.01-Closes[1][0]=92.01-147
      24441-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92-Closes[1][0]=92-147
      24442-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=92-Closes[1][0]=92-147
      24443-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.99-Closes[1][0]=91.99-147
      24444-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.99-Closes[1][0]=91.99-147
      24445-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.98-Closes[1][0]=91.98-147
      24446-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.97-Closes[1][0]=91.97-147
      24447-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.96-Closes[1][0]=91.96-147
      24448-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.96-Closes[1][0]=91.96-147
      24449-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.98-Closes[1][0]=91.98-147
      24450-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.98-Closes[1][0]=91.98-147
      24451-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.98-Closes[1][0]=91.98-147
      24452-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.98-Closes[1][0]=91.98-147
      24453-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.98-Closes[1][0]=91.98-147
      24454-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.97-Closes[1][0]=91.97-147
      24455-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.99-Closes[1][0]=91.99-147
      24456-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.98-Closes[1][0]=91.98-147
      24457-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.98-Closes[1][0]=91.98-147
      24458-Opens[0][0]=91.95-Opens[1][0]=91.98-Closes[1][0]=91.98-147
      24459-Opens[0][0]=91.99-Opens[1][0]=91.97-Closes[1][0]=91.97-148
      24459-Opens[0][0]=91.99-Opens[1][0]=91.97-Closes[1][0]=91.97-148
      24460-Opens[0][0]=91.99-Opens[1][0]=91.97-Closes[1][0]=91.97-148
      24461-Opens[0][0]=91.99-Opens[1][0]=91.97-Closes[1][0]=91.97-148
      24462-Opens[0][0]=91.99-Opens[1][0]=91.98-Closes[1][0]=91.98-148
      Last edited by afshinmoshrefi; 01-09-2013, 02:14 PM.

      Comment


        #4
        Hello afshinmoshrefi,
        Thanks for the clarification.

        If you try re-downloading the tick data using the Download feature of NinjaTrader then are you able to replicate the behavior.
        JoydeepNinjaTrader Customer Service

        Comment

        Latest Posts

        Collapse

        Topics Statistics Last Post
        Started by Geovanny Suaza, 02-11-2026, 06:32 PM
        0 responses
        661 views
        0 likes
        Last Post Geovanny Suaza  
        Started by Geovanny Suaza, 02-11-2026, 05:51 PM
        0 responses
        375 views
        1 like
        Last Post Geovanny Suaza  
        Started by Mindset, 02-09-2026, 11:44 AM
        0 responses
        110 views
        0 likes
        Last Post Mindset
        by Mindset
         
        Started by Geovanny Suaza, 02-02-2026, 12:30 PM
        0 responses
        574 views
        1 like
        Last Post Geovanny Suaza  
        Started by RFrosty, 01-28-2026, 06:49 PM
        0 responses
        579 views
        1 like
        Last Post RFrosty
        by RFrosty
         
        Working...
        X