replay pnl errors

[ATI user]

how can the pnl be 2189.72 when the cash value profit is 3263.23 ??

this is with the trades flat

[NinjaTrader_Brett]

Hello,

Thanks for the forum post.

I'm not sure where your replay value was before the realized PnL started. Can you reproduce this with a fresh screenshot showing the starting value of the account and the ending value?

If so then I will want to test this on my side in this case.

Let me know if I can be of further assistance.

[ATI user]

replay 101 always starts at 0 realized and at the initial account value, in this case 100,000

[NinjaTrader_Brett]

This is not always the case.

This value can be changed by resetting the Replay account value under the control center->tools->options->simulator tab->change initial value then click reset->select Replay101 account.

Please reset the replay101 account manually to 100,000 the retest and let me know.

Thank You.

[ATI user]

in four years replay has always reset on rewind...and it still is

so problem is not starting amount but rather accumulated amounts after trading begins

[NinjaTrader_Brett]

ATI,

Understood however starting value can be changed on what it resets with. This would change the outcome.

Need a reproduce scenario on my side. I have tested this with no problems.

Can you reproduce it on your side?

If so we will want to schedule a time for me to login to your PC and watch the reproduce steps.

Thanks.