Different Chart by "Days back"

[ronner]

I think the problem is that each chart starts at different time

This idea sounds good.

Try to put BarTimer on each and see.

thx, i try it later.

Does the difference persists.

no - on Rangebar and Tick it is okay. Only on secondcharts and renkochart (Eds Renko) is it wrong.

I suggest to make use of the same look back period of 5 days for each chart.

Yes, but what interval is the right / best ? 1,2,3,4,5 ? That is the question .

[NinjaTrader_Jason]

Hello ronner,

I suggest to use 5 days back so you have quite some historical data in your chart.

Baruch, thank you for your contribution.

[ronner]

I suggest to use 5 days back so you have quite some historical data in your chart.

yes, i will do it so.

Perhaps in NT7 it is correctly, this would be great .

Thanks for the nice support Jason and Baruch !

[edsfreedom]

no - on Rangebar and Tick it is okay. Only on secondcharts and renkochart (Eds Renko) is it wrong.

I think the problem is that each chart starts at different time (few seconds difference).

Yes I believe the issue is due to the different time/price that the first bar is made. Volume charts has a similar problem with EdsRenko in that different starting time/price will yield a shifted pricing chart (candle looking a little bit different). However, I don't understand how come Rangebars do not exhibit this problem.

[edsfreedom]

Yes I believe the issue is due to the different time/price that the first bar is made. Volume charts has a similar problem with EdsRenko in that different starting time/price will yield a shifted pricing chart (candle looking a little bit different). However, I don't understand how come Rangebars do not exhibit this problem.

I think I have a solution for Renko: Try to synchronize the first bar/price as the denominator of that tick price. Which means the first open of the bar does not start until price hits a denomination of the tick price. I'll try this in the next couple of days when I have time to code and test.

[edsfreedom]

For EdsRenko, just added synchronizing the first bar open price to multiple of renko brick size so bars look the same regardless of days back.

[ronner]

For EdsRenko, just added synchronizing the first bar open price to multiple of renko brick size so bars look the same regardless of days back.

thx Ed,

it works now perfectly