VSA Indicator - Beta

[suncity93]

Hello
Do you have "VPA" indicator for Ninja Trader 8?

[asmmbillah]

It will be really helpful and enrich NT8, if it had VSA indicator.

[sunlounger]

Hello everybody, can somebody please help with a simple VSA indicator. I create my owns using the strategy builder, but this one needs to be coded so I could use it to code a strategy (which actualy will be an indicator)

It is very simple, I just need the ratio between the volume and the range of the bar (difference between high and low). Should be displayed the same way that the built in ninja trader volume indicator is displayed, like a histogram and showing the number while the bar is creating.

Thank You

[aligator]

Hello everybody, can somebody please help with a simple VSA indicator. I create my owns using the strategy builder, but this one needs to be coded so I could use it to code a strategy (which actualy will be an indicator)

It is very simple, I just need the ratio between the volume and the range of the bar (difference between high and low). Should be displayed the same way that the built in ninja trader volume indicator is displayed, like a histogram and showing the number while the bar is creating.

Thank You

Old thread here, be specific, VPA or VPS. Post the latest NT7 version here and someone may convert it to NT8.

[aligator]

Hello
Do you have "VPA" indicator for Ninja Trader 8?

If you did a little search in the forum you would find it here:

https://ninjatraderecosystem.com/user-app-share-download/vpa-indicator-nt8/

[aligator]

A major complementary indicator to VPA, based on an important aspect of Wyckoff Method, is the Effort Versus Result Index indicator used by Karthik along with VPA. The usefulness of the Effort Index indicator is demonstrated by Karthik in this video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iyD3TZTaxmk

Unfortunately, there is no NT8 version of this indicator, however an Afl version is available (Attached). It is simple enough and perhaps someone is willing to convert it to Ninja and share it here.

Cheers!

[punkiy2111]

Good afternoon, I would like to know if there is a forum or videos to understand how this indicator works. Thank you very much to all.

[NinjaTrader_Kate]

Hello punkiy2111,

Thank you for your reply.

A number of indicators are mentioned on this thread - VPA, VPS and Effort Index. You may want to add which specifically you are looking for instruction videos on to make it easier for other users to help you. As none of these indicators are included with NinjaTrader, we would not have any videos on how these work. However, other forum users may be able to assist where we cannot.

Please let us know if we may be of further assistance to you.

[punkiy2111]

Hello punkiy2111,

Thank you for your reply.

A number of indicators are mentioned on this thread - VPA, VPS and Effort Index. You may want to add which specifically you are looking for instruction videos on to make it easier for other users to help you. As none of these indicators are included with NinjaTrader, we would not have any videos on how these work. However, other forum users may be able to assist where we cannot.

Please let us know if we may be of further assistance to you.

Hello, thanks for answering, I am sincerely interested in the 3 indicators that are spoken in this thread. If someone can help me either comment here or send private. Thank you.

[mattcrown]

hello, thanks for answering, i am sincerely interested in the 3 indicators that are spoken in this thread. If someone can help me either comment here or send private. Thank you.

this is helpful

[ATTACH=JSON]n1233709[/ATTACH]

[jb805]

Where is an explanation of the VPA indicator?

[diegomezhur]

Good evening! After the release of NT8.1 the indicator Update for "VPA Indicator NT8 By NinjaTrader_Jim" shows and error saying the Ninjascript archive file may contain dulicate method names. I was using this version of the iindicator to plot alerts. Any solutions for this issue? Thanks in advance.

[NinjaTrader_ChelseaB]

Hello diegomezhur,

Welcome to the NinjaTrader forums!

I've send a pm to Tradarr the author of this User App Script to inform them there may be an issue with their custom script.

[aligator]

Good evening! After the release of NT8.1 the indicator Update for "VPA Indicator NT8 By NinjaTrader_Jim" shows and error saying the Ninjascript archive file may contain dulicate method names. I was using this version of the iindicator to plot alerts. Any solutions for this issue? Thanks in advance.

Hi.
Most likely you have another version of the VPA that is using the same Method name in your new Update version. Search in your list of Indicators, Strategies, and Market Analzer for a VPA file. If you find another VPA file other than your updated version, remove to some temp location (do not delete, in case) and try to run the update version and see if the issue goes away. It is possible the peson who wrote the Update version may have placed it in his own name subfolder file under the indicators, etc.

[fripi]

I have the same error message, and don't find any other VSA/VPA indicator, in the log files I also see some strange stuff, like missing code

2025-01-07 11:17:04:648 WARNING: Error compiling import assembly: E:\Documents\NinjaTrader 8\tmp\Import\Files\bin\Custom\Indicators\DarrellW\ VPA.cs(209,26): error CS0103: The name 'Wilder' does not exist in the current context
2025-01-07 11:17:04:648 WARNING: Error compiling import assembly: E:\Documents\NinjaTrader 8\tmp\Import\Files\bin\Custom\Indicators\DarrellW\ VPA.cs(226,34): error CS0103: The name 'LinRegSlopeSFX' does not exist in the current context
2025-01-07 11:17:04:648 WARNING: Error compiling import assembly: E:\Documents\NinjaTrader 8\tmp\Import\Files\bin\Custom\Indicators\DarrellW\ VPA.cs(227,36): error CS0103: The name 'LinRegSlopeSFX' does not exist in the current context
2025-01-07 11:17:04:648 WARNING: Error compiling import assembly: E:\Documents\NinjaTrader 8\tmp\Import\Files\bin\Custom\Indicators\DarrellW\ VPA.cs(228,35): error CS0103: The name 'LinRegSlopeSFX' does not exist in the current context

and in the code of the indicator I found those

avgSpread = (Wilder(spread, VolumeEmaAve)[0]);
LongTermTrendSlope = LinRegSlopeSFX(fiveDaysSma, 40, false, 1)[0];
MiddleTermTrendSlope = LinRegSlopeSFX(fiveDaysSma, 15, false, 1)[0];
ShortTermTrendSlope = LinRegSlopeSFX(fiveDaysSma, 5, false, 1)[0];